GAS HEATERS VS DIESEL HEATERS
Came across this great read by the rv plumber .
Being winter, we have been inundated with calls about which is better, Gas or Diesel? We found this article great to help our customers make an informed decision without been convinced to purchase something that does not suit their needs.
Truma Gas Heater
Truma E2400 Gas Heater
Heating Power – 2400 Watts
Air Flow – 78 cubic meters per hour
Power Consumption – 0.6 to 1.1 amp @ 12v
Fuel Consumption – 170 grams/hour LPG
Weight – 4.7 kg
Dimensions – 370mm (plus 47mm gas inlet) x 248mm x 123mm high
Max. outlets – 2
Eberspacher Airtronic D2 Diesel Heater
Eberspacher Diesel Heater
Heating Power – 2200 Watts
Air Flow – 87 cubic meters per hour
Power Consumption – 0.67 to 2.83 amp @ 12v
Fuel Consumption – 0.15 to 0.23 litres/hour DIESEL
Weight – 2.5 kg
Dimensions – 122mm x 310mm x 115mm high
Max. outlets – 2
Webasto Air Top 2000STC
Heating Power – 2000 Watts
Air Flow – 93 cubic meters per hour
Power Consumption – 1.16 to 2.41 amp @ 12v
Fuel Consumption – 0.12 to 0.24 litres/hour DIESEL
Weight – 2.6 kg
Dimensions – 120mm x 311mm x 121mm highh
Max. outlets – 2
Which One is Better?
Both heaters are the perfect addition to the caravan for the modern traveller. And based on the specifications above, not one stands out above the rest. The fuel consumption is relatively similar in comparison. 10 litres of diesel would last of 43 hours, and a 9kg gas bottle would run the heater for 52 hours. Keeping in mind that this consumption is based on maximum consumption.
Both heaters are completely sealed burners, meaning the oxygen used in combustion is drawn from outside and exhaust fumes are expelled outside.
For the typical 18 to 24 ft caravan, half an hour is enough time for these heaters to heat up the space to a more than comfortable temperature. Both heaters have built in thermostats to maintain that comfortable setting.
The Eberspacher and Webasto Diesel heater has three burner settings which it automatically selects during operation, based on the thermostat reading. This makes the Diesel Heater very fuel efficient, and allows the heater to maintain a constant temperature. Sometimes a small adjustment of temperature setting is required to allow the heater to maintain temperature while operating on it’s low setting, which is the best situation as while in low setting, it is even more quieter than the Truma E2400 gas heater when operating on it’s low setting.
The E2400 gas heater only has On and Off setting which is automatically controlled by the thermostat, the thermostat has a setting of 1 to 5, this means that it can be a little bit more temperamental when trying to maintain a constant temperature.
The location of the heater can play an important part in how well it will heat the van. For the typical layout of the double bed up the front of the van, with a middle kitchen/dining area, the best location is under the bed with an outlet pointing straight down the centre isle of the living area. This creates the best flow of air.
The location is also determined by regulation factors. The gas heater flue cannot be installed too close to a window, door, other gas appliance inlet or outlet, or under an enclosed annexe. These regulations will sometimes rule out the possibility of installing a gas heater, in which case a diesel heater would be the way to go.
The diesel heater does not have a flue that goes through the wall like the gas heater does, it has an exhaust that goes through the floor of the caravan. This requires clear space directly below the heater location.
The Webasto 2000 STC Diesel Heater now comes with an air intake silencer, exhaust muffler and updated fuel pump which is 10dB quieter than previous Webasto models. The Eberspacher has the option of an air intake silencer, but it is not a standard item in the kit. The Webasto now also has a digital programmable timer as standard in the kit, whereas it previously only had a rheostat dial controller. I, The RV Plumber is now installing Webasto diesel heaters rather than the Eberspacher heaters.
If you still can’t decide which one to go for, consider this; Do you want to carry extra diesel? And do you have a suitable spot for the diesel tank to be installed on the caravan or motorhome? There are different options for the diesel tank. The best thing for you to do is have a think about some different locations that might work, and tell me about them when calling for your over the phone quote.
In my opinion, diesel heaters are better for aftermarket installations. The gas ducted heater such as the E2400 is more ideally installed during manufacturing stages to allow for it’s suitable location during design stages, based on the Gas Installation Standards.
Using diesel fuel to heat the RV is a good way to maximise your ability to free camp in remote locations without the need to go and refuel or refill gas cylinders. Save your LPG for your fridge, HWS and cooktop.
The BIG Question; Are they noisy?
I would definitely not consider the gas heater to be noisy. The only part you hear on these is the fan, which is a considerable amount quitter than rooftop air conditioners.
The diesel heater (Dometic Eberspacher D2) is louder than the gas heater (Truma E2400). The motor of the diesel heater is a bit more powerful and has the capacity to push more air, creating a little more noise than the gas heater. It is still considerably more quiet than rooftop air conditioners.
Outside, underneath the RV is the fuel pump, combustion air intake and exhaust of the diesel heater. These parts also contribute to the noise of the heater. The air intake and exhaust are a bit louder than the noise of the internal fan, but hardly noticed from inside the van. The fuel pump is most likely the one to upset you or your neighbouring camps. The fuel pump ticks, it’s not overly loud, but it’s just the right pitch to be heard easily, and if possible the fuel pump would best be installed further away from the sleeping area as possible.
Keep in mind that the many comments you read on the forums about noisy fuel pumps, might be a reflection of the fact that many caravaners DIY their diesel heater installations. And possibly refer to the cheaper eBay diesel heaters. Eberspacher provides the best fuel pump mount, which if installed correctly can substantially reduce the noise heard from the fuel pump in comparison to the Planar fuel pump mount.
The Webasto Air Top 2000 STC now comes standard with an air intake silencer, exhaust muffler and an updated fuel pump which is 10dB quieter than previous Webasto models.
Will you sleep with the heater on during the night? It is perfectly safe to do so, however most of my customers say no
Eberspacher or Webasto Diesel Heater?
In my opinion they are equally as good as each other in their reliability and quality of product. For a long time my preference was the Eberspacher as it came standard with a digital controller, and a good quality rubber fuel pump mount, as well as the exhaust muffler as standard. Now that the Webasto Air Top 2000 STC Diesel Heater comes standard with a digital programmable controller, upgraded fuel pump which is 10dB quieter than previous Webasto models, exhaust muffler and an air intake silencer. Webasto is now my choice of heater and will be my standard supplied heater that I install.
The RV Plumper
The RV Technicians Pty Ltd offers a complete caravan services workshop.
Offering brakes and bearings, repairs for damaged caravans, upgrades,
modifications and aftermarket accessories.
The team offers a combined industry experience of over 30 years in the Manufacturing, Repairs and Servicing sector of the Caravan and Motorhome Industry.
The RV Plumber has provided quality service for many years in the RV industry. Specialising in Diesel Heaters and Gas Heaters for caravans and full plumbing system installations.
Located in the Yarra Valley, east of Melbourne, with a conveniently located workshop on the Warburton Highway. Some on-site services are available to customers located in the Yarra Valley.
With extensive product knowledge, comes specialised advice and support